How to find Consistent Value-creating Companies

The first and foremost question one should ask when deciding to invest into a company is whether the company is a good quality one, worthy of our money. If it is not then it is something you should buy at any price. So how do we answer this?

Every company is essentially money using and money generating entity. A company must generate returns more than its cost of capital to justify its existence. Return on capital employed (RoCE) is the single most important ratio which tells you how efficiently the company is utilizing its funds, both shareholder as well as what it has used from the lenders to the business.

To assess the cost of capital we look at the firm’s Weighted Average Cost of Capital, (known as WACC and pronounced as wack), the combined cost of its equity and debt in their proportion. RoCE in excess of WACC means that the company is adding value and this excess return is called as economic value added.

Is Economic Value Added the only metric one need to know about?

As investors we would like companies to reinvest profits in growing the business for the future and any excess beyond that should come back to us in the form of dividends or buybacks. But, a company may reinvest all their profits, or maybe even more into capital projects, and not generate the returns in line with its existing line of business. However, this will become visible after the investments have been done.

To resolve this we look at the operating cash flow, since it is the actual cash generated after adjustments for working capital and depreciation and deduct the capital investments from this, to arrive at what is called the Free Cash Flow, FCF. We would prefer companies with high FCF.

To summarize, a company that can maintain a healthy RoCE and generating a healthy cash flow even when making required capital investments is a consistent value creating company, worthy of our money. A company having healthy RoCE but poor free cash flow must be investigated further.

How to know whether the value-creating company will continue to grow the profits in the future?

A strong track record of growth in sales and profits over the last 10 years is a good indicator that the company could grow in the future, especially if this period includes a few years of tough market situation. While the past is not a guarantee for the future, a strong track record over years does indicate a strong management, capable of delivering good performance through good times and bad.

Additionally, when the company grows it needs to invest in higher working capital and capacity expansion. Book value per share (BVPS) tells you how much the company is investing in itself and hence ready for the future.

So an efficient company with growth in EPS, sales and BVPS is a strong indicator of company’s ability to create value consistently. But if the sales and BVPS have grown faster than EPS, one would not be very pleased as an investor. Slower sales growth should make you even more cautious.

What could be the pitfall to watch out for?

When there is an economic up cycle, the future looks rosy and many companies tend to take advantage of the situation and go on a debt-fuelled expansion spree. Now, as you know, debt is double edged sword, which helps in boosting these metrics, thus making the business look extremely attractive. But when the economy goes through a downturns, the same debt deals a double whammy to the company, as the profits are subdued, but additionally, the company has an additional burden on making its payments, thus destroying shareholder wealth.